The impulse delivered to the ball is equal to the ball's change in momentum, and the presence of the mitt does not change this, eliminating A and C. The extra area may decrease the pressure on the catcher's hand, but not the force (eliminating B). The padding of the mitt causes the time during which the ball comes to a stop to increase (just as an air bag increases the time it takes for an automobile passenger involved in an accident to come to a stop), which decreases the magnitude of the ball's acceleration (since a = (delta)v/(delta)t). A decrease in the magnitude of the acceleration means a decrease in the magnitude of the force (since a = F/m).